| 1. Henry Davis | 1849 |
| 2. Sanders | 1882 |
| 3. E.H. Baker | 1905 |
| 4. J.C. Conway | 1909 |
| 5. H.S. Morrill | 1910-12 |
| 6. C.H. Dayton | 1913-14 |
| 7. R.E. Carney | 1914-16 |
| 8. J.C. Conway | 1917 |
| 9. J.R. Hastings | 1918 |
| 10. J.L Duff | 1920 |
| 11. E.H. Turner | 1922-23 |
| 12. C.W. Swift | 1923-25 |
| 13. J.W. Allen | 1927-30 |
| 14. C.J. Hazen | 1931 |
| 15. W.S. Whiteman | 1932-34 |
| 16. J.D. Shorney | 1935-37 |
| 17. Guynn | 1938-39 |
| 18. C.C. Ohlson | 1940-41 |
| 19. Elmer Smart | 1945-48 |
| 20. Garfield Rogers | 1949-52 |
| 21. Bill Nelson | 1952-58 |
| 22. Quentin Wilson | 1958-59 |
| 23. Lon Springer | 1960-63 |
| 24. Ross Pace | 1964-66 |
| 25. Bryan Johnson | 1966-70 |
| 26. Eugene Owsley | 1971-72 |
| 27. Elmer Smart | 1973-74 |
| 28. Dean Smith | 1975-77 |
| 29. Kim Gee | 1977-81 |
| 30. Durwin Burtz | 1981-85 |
| 31. Gene McIntosh | 1986-92 |
| 32. Thomas Rittichier | 1993-98 |
| 33. Jason Thacker | 1999-2004 |
| 34. Larry Lindow | 2005- |
Various men served as our interim pastors during these 150 plus years, for which we are eternally grateful!
| Ray Osterhouse | 1963 & 72 |
| R. Pady | 1964 |
| Lyle Bullard | 1972 |
| Lon Springer | 1986 |
| Glen Prewitt | 1992-93 & 1998-99 |